PostDoc Unions: Good Idea, or not?

ScienceInsider is reporting that Rutgers University postdocs have formed a union.  Rutgers becomes (at least) the third school in the nation to organize into a union, joining the UC system and the University of Connecticut Health Center in Farmington (edit: and it seems University of Washington and University of Massachusetts)

Is this a good idea or a bad idea?  Postdocs are sort of the limbo of the graduate/professional career.  Sometimes you need one more bullet point on your resume.  Sometimes you’re learning a new field to be a good well rounded scientist.  Sometimes it just feels like what ‘everyone does’ before that first real job.

You’re in the lab with grad students, but you’re not a grad student.  You’re paid better, and generally have more freedoms… but still bend to the will of the PI/research group.  No worrying about cumes or orals or dissertations, but sometimes feeling like you’re in a constant cycle of applying for real jobs.

The lead organizer of the union movement at Rutgers is quoted as saying, “By unionizing, we joined the rest of the university community.”  They’ll begin contract negotiations in the fall on issues such as wage, paid sickleave, benefits, childcare, and others.  But due to the transient nature of the postdoc position, not everyone feels it makes sense to organize.  Turnover is realatively high in the postdoc field.  Some UC postdocs also noted some questionable behavior on the part of union organizers as signatures were being gathered.

UC postdocs currently do not have a contract, despite having voted to organize almost a year ago.  You can follow the progress of contract negotiations here.  One of the updates notes a consequence of organizing during a state-wide budget crisis (emphasis in original):

[UC system] President [Mark] Yudof has publicly proposed in his June 17 letter to the UC community pay cuts and/or furloughs for all UC employees, including Postdocs. President Yudof is proposing to raise this issue with the UC Regents on July 14 and 15. To be perfectly clear, wages and leaves are mandatory topics of bargaining. Since we have formed a union and are in contract negotiations, NO CHANGES CAN BE MADE TO POSTDOC TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF WORK WITHOUT BARGAINING THE CHANGES WITH PRO/UAW.

So what do you think?  Are postdoc unions a good idea or a bad idea?  What about graduate student unions?  What would it mean if the postdoc union went on strike?  What benefits would organizing bring to the postdoc landscape?

15 Comments

  1. I’m split on the issue. I personally don’t like the idea of forming unions because University research is more of a lifestyle and less of a job. You’re expected to work hard in grad school (both as a student and postdoc) and constantly be thinking about research.

    That said, I’d like to see a nation-wide graduate student bill of rights. Such a document could clearly define a student’s roles and responsibilities. In my experience, many profs treat their grad students like sub-human help and blatantly dismiss the fact that their “employees” have personal needs/responsibilities. I recall several instances where professors abused their “powers” to make grad students perform mundane, irrelevant tasks (seemingly because they could) that ultimately ended up wasting time. Wasn’t so much of a problem for me, but a co-worker friend of mine had a wife and kids at home who were more important than regrading 300 exams for a third time.

  2. I’m not a big fan of postdoc unions because I think it contributes to the normalization of the postdoc as a “job.” Postdocs are supposed to be 2-3 year apprenticeships where you accept half the salary you could otherwise earn in exchange for exposure to some new skills and/or the opportunity to churn out papers. Developments like unions suggest that it’s reasonable to hire incredibly highly trained 30-somethings with families as technicians for years on end and then only pay them 30-40k a year.

    It also doesn’t make sense to me to pay into a union when I only expect to be a postdoc for a very short time, and where the threat of a strike would hurt me more than my PI.

  3. I agree with Matt. A postdoc is not supposed to be a job — I am unaware of people unionizing that sort of limbo-like state.

    Ultimately, this is the outgrowth of the oversupply of biological science Ph.D.s. Forming postdoc unions is a solution for the symptom, not the underlying problem.

    If multiple postdocs among chemistry PhDs becomes a trend, we are in real trouble.

    (Then again, it could be that they’re trying to MAKE it impossible for academics to have too many postdocs (by raising the cost). But then where will the pushed-out postdocs go? The job market doesn’t seem to be soaking them up…)

    • At the same time, having so many (likely) Chinese nationals become union members would be a really interesting political phenomenon — would they try to sneak this back home with them?

  4. Post-Doc unions are bad. It would only make things worse and make industry even more afraid of PhDs.

    If bachelor degree holders were allowed to advance to the levels of PhD holders in industry through their work there (not academia) than there would be far fewer PhDs and unions would not be necessary. This is practiced in Japan, it’s called ronbun.

    The academic pipeline is clogged because only one way is being given to students to advance their scientific careers, PhD research. We need another way!!

  5. Apparently there are more folks at UC who are not happy with unionization: http://ucpostdocs.wordpress.com/ I don’t know if they will be successful in their attempt at decertification but for sure the UAW people will get pretty tough on them 🙂

  6. This is good idea

  7. I like reading through a post that will make men and women think. Also, thanks for allowing for me to comment!

  8. I’d like to find out more? I’d want to find out more details.

  9. There is a praoclaiming that gold is measured by karats, which is true to a specific extent but in actuality the grade of gold matters not until it really is used just as one investment. Responsible adults work with decades, and expect you’ll be rewarded for efforts. Be sure to do your own research and discover the corporation that best suites you.

  10. Your employer can also be required to provide staff using the appropriate training and data to ensure they are aware how to keep safe in the workplace. By following common sense, protection procedures, it really is extremely safe and everyone can do it. Today, several manufacturers provide you with the compound in a very synthetic version.

  11. Around every corner there’s something new and relevant and also you don’t need to travel long distances to see a great deal, and it can be reassuring to know that there is a good hotel awaiting your return. The cost is determined by the level of comfort that you would like to take pleasure from with this lovely touring experience. Rachel Corrie was an American human rights activist, who in 2003 with the chronilogical age of 23 was unlawfully crushed to death by an Israeli Defense Force bulldozer, while peacefully protesting from the demolition of your Doctors home inside Gaza strip.

  12. human hair wig short bob style gray wig

    hair extensions If Jim Bob Pickens has owned a dry cleaners for 20 years, he probably knew he wasn allowed to dispose of his waste chemicals in the creek behind his house. But if he gets on the stand and convincingly plays an uneducated hick in front of the jury, and there aren records the state can produce of him being told that doing so was improper disposal, the jury is going to have reasonable doubt that he intentionally broke the law. And if intentionally disposing of the chemicals in an improper way is what he charged with, then he gets off scott free. hair extensions

    tape in extensions Procurement audit results, an input to the Contract Closeout process B. Other project records, an input to the Administrative Closure process C. Project reports, an input to the Contract Closeout process D. Please do not use Hair Drier or Put the wig expose to Intense HearStock photos are taken in natural light with no flash. It fits on most people. All you need to do is to adjust the hooks inside the cap to the correct size to suit your headThe item is Easy to wash and care just using a little mild shampoo in cold water. tape in extensions

    I Tip extensions The 1920s Flapper DressFLAPPERS DID AWAY WITH CORSETS AND PANTALOOMS AND HENCE APPEARED THE. ‘STEP IN PANTIES’. The new boyish look was now the new rage.The woman’s body now had a up and down look with the straight up and down dresses they now attired themselves with.Bras were actually sold to flatten the bust line not to emphasise it.This was a time in history where there was an obvious move away from the showing of the female curves in favour of this new look. I Tip extensions

    clip in extensions The women now wear dark wigs to look more “Latin American.”[W]ith Viva Maria!, which aims at being little more than a fancifully photographed tale of two turn of the century dance hall girls who cheer up a Latin American revolution, Moreau saw a chance of expressing one of her firmest beliefs. ‘Films have never shown the kind of relationship that can exist between two women,’ she says. ‘Men like to think that women must be constantly jealous of each other, never trusting, never in rapport. clip in extensions

    human hair wigs The lyrics to the song are another “story”. You are so right. I enjoyed your comment. I had multiple tracts and I also have a connective tissue disorder that causes my healing to be slow and scar tissue to be weak. I am the worst case scenario. I am not typical. The shifting economics away from the Old World to the New created a period of hyper self indulgence in the US known as the Gilded Age,[2] in which every measure of wealth, productivity and well being skyrocketed. The new super rich built on a magnificent scale and the collection of European Art and artefacts into the US gathered pace. Because of less human traffic, studies can be places for household pests to live, and this chapter talks about humans and pests. human hair wigs

    lace front wigs The team of this period also included future Hall of Famers Ferguson Jenkins and Billy Williams and a guy who should be in The Hall: Ron Santo. Jenkins won 20 games or more six consecutive seasons as the Cubs ace pitcher, and still today is one of only four baseball pitchers in the history of the game to have logged over 3000 strikeouts of batters while walking less than 1000 of them. He also pitched the complete game an amazing 267 times lace front wigs.
    360 Lace wigs

  13. I am truly delighted to glance at this website posts which includes tons of useful facts, thanks for providing these statistics.

  14. I am truly delighted to glance at this website posts which includes tons of useful facts, thanks for providing these statistics.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *