Hello, everyone! Since this is my first post on Chemistry Blog, I should introduce myself. My name is Nick, and I’m a Ph.D. student in organic chemistry at McGill University, in Montreal. Mitch contacted me via the chemistry subreddit, and I’ll be writing a few articles with what I hope is a unique perspective. In advance, I would ask that you excuse my Canadian spellings; the letter “u” will pop up a lot more often than you’re used to.
As anyone who regularly reads scientific journals may have noticed, Wiley redesigned some of their website earlier this year. Mid-way through the summer, they slicked up their Interscience pages to look more “Web 2.0″, and in the process, broke integration with one of my favourite things, which is Zotero. Zotero was previously mentioned on the site quite some time ago, as one of several reference management programs available to modern researchers. Given that it’s free, absurdly easy to use, efficient, fast, allows proxies, and acts as a bridge between OpenOffice and Firefox (with downloadable reference formats), I unabashedly support the abandonement of every other reference management system in favour of it. Zotero makes collecting references and writing papers a breeze, and a whole lot more enjoyable than any other option I’ve tried.
What Wiley did to break Zotero’s flow was very simple. Instead of having direct links to actual PDF files as part of their abstract pages (as nearly every other online publishing website does), they now direct you to a PDF file within an “iframe”, meaning that Zotero is not able to “see” the PDF as an actual PDF. This allows them to place a highly annoying “Wiley Interscience” bar at the top, including your institutional logo, and links to citing articles, abstract, and supplementary info, as seen blow.
This would be okay, except that with Zotero absolutely none of those links are necessary. When you do the one-click save on an abstract it automatically generates a snapshot of the abstract page, including links to all that information. Normally, it also saves a copy of the PDF, but Wiley has now made this significantly more complicated. You must now either save the iframe page as a snapshot (including the annoying header and useless links), or download the PDF separately, import into Zotero, then delete the original download to avoid having duplicate copies on your hard drive. So basically, instead of a one-click save, you now have an option of a four-step non-PDF download (via the “add item” button, seen above at the bottom left), or a five-step (take snapshot, navigate to “pdf”, download, import, delete) rigmarole.
Compare this to ACS Publications, or ScienceDirect, where you click once on the address bar icon, and get all the above done in about 5 seconds (see below), or even ThiemeConnect, where you simply have to add the PDF as a separate item, and Wiley’s “site improvements” actually begin to look like a big step backwards.
I’ve e-mailed Wiley about this twice, and it seems that their support staff have no idea what Zotero is, or why this is important, and don’t seem to care. Ultimately this isn’t a huge issue, but I would really love to see a return to the old functionality; as it stands right now I cringe every time I see a paper I want hosted by Wiley Interscience.